College Media Network - Search the largest news resource for college students by college students Jobs and internships for students -

DADT policy not ready for revocation

The Don’t ask Don’t tell Policy was implemented for a reason, and therefore should not be revoked.

Published: Tuesday, March 2, 2010

Updated: Tuesday, March 2, 2010

The Don’t ask Don’t tell Policy was implemented for a reason, and therefore should not be revoked.     


Currently, the policy is outlined as don’t ask, don’t tell, don’t harass, don’t pursue.


This policy prevents the service men and women to express their gay, lesbian, orbisexual orientation to the United States military. The policy also restricts the military from efforts to reveal closeted gay, lesbian, or bisexual individuals.


 “Don’t ask don’t tell” was created in the early 90s to allow citizens to serve in the military regardless of their sexual orientation.  It was implemented so that the military was no longer discriminating toward anyone’s sexual orientation.


Back before the 90s there were no gay, lesbian, or bisexual individuals allowed in the military at all. For the military to change its policy in the first place shows that there may be potential in the future.  


Although we have come a long way since this policy was enacted, Americans still aren’t as accepting as they should be of gay, lesbian, and bisexual individuals and couples.
When a gay, lesbian, or bisexual individual is sworn into the military under oath, he or she is agreeing to abide by many rules and regulations and must conduct themselves the way the military dictates. This means they are not allowed to be open about their sexual stance.


There are already so many codes of conduct in the military that perhaps we should ask individuals in the military what they want.  After all, they will have to live with the decision that the government makes.


In the United States of America, we have the freedom of choice. When a civilian makes the choice to enter military service, he or she is making the commitment to serve their country.


The military is currently a choice and not a mandatory draft, therefore the “Don’t ask don’t tell” policy is another policy that the military has enacted to prevent discrimination.
When sworn into the military you are under oath and swear to protect your country. This oath does not ask you to be someone you are not, and still allows you to pursue life, liberty and happiness.


It asks you to protect the civil liberties of our nation.  It asks you to withhold speaking about your personal sexual preferences.


President Obama said that he will end the “Don’t ask don’t tell” policy on gays and bisexuals in the military, but we should not do so with such haste.


In order to revoke the “Don’t ask don’t tell” policy, the military might have to add additional services to accommodate their gay, lesbian, and bisexual community. This may include separate housing; in revoking the policy the military will have to take further measures to make the entire community feel more comfortable.


We could revoke the “Don’t ask, don’t tell” policy but America hasn’t evolved enough yet.

 

Recommended: Articles that may interest you

1 comments Log in to Comment

Steve Clark Hall
Wed Mar 3 2010 01:15
Lets get real and stick to facts rather than try to grasp outdated hysteria about sexual minorities.

First of all, there has ALWAYS been gay and lesbians serving their country in our military. I was one of those who served for 22 years prior to the implementation of the current policy. “Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell” did not open the door for sexual minorities to join, it only eliminated the cruel, demeaning and wasteful witch-hunts that were little more than a job security program for the service investigative commands such as the NIS (later renamed the NCIS to give the appearance that they had something to do with crimes.)

So how many enlistees really take the oath of office as gay people attempting to infiltrate our military? The “Out of Annapolis Study” showed that only about 12% of that group identified as gay or lesbian upon entry into the service. 61% re-identified as gay or lesbian while in the service and the remaining 27% didn’t identify at all while they were in on active duty in the military. So what do you propose we do with that kid who has taken the oath, undergone basic and advanced training, is fully integrated in to his/her unit and then comes to the realization that he/she is gay or lesbian?

My guess is that as one in favor of the current policy, you never served. I did, and as a unit commander (I was the Commanding Officer of Nuclear Submarines) I can tell you first hand how much it hurts your unit’s readiness when you have that one sailor who raises his/her hand and says “get me out of here, I’m gay.”

We’ve lived through one entire generation since “Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell” was formulated. It was a terrible policy when put into effect 16 years ago, and it has only grown to be even more so.

It’s time for those who have never served and those who served generations ago to let go of their unfounded, baseless fears. We already know what will happen based on the integration of gays and lesbians in every other military force in NATO except the Turks (and with their genocide record, do we want to be like with them?) -- NOTHING!

It’s way past due to eliminate this shameful, hurtful and counter-productive policy.

You must be logged in to comment on an article. Not already a member? Register now

Log In